Saturday, August 2, 2025

Why Robert Zemeckis’ CGI Beatles Film Was Canceled






As a Brit, I could also be a bit biased once I say this: The opening ceremony for the London 2012 Summer season Olympics was one of the best ever. Directed by Danny Boyle, the standard hour of dancers and acrobats twirling round was spectacular and foolish, full with skits celebrating the Industrial Revolution, the NHS, and the nation’s wealthy cultural scene. Film buffs additionally bought two particular treats: Rowan Atkinson as Mr. Bean daydreaming about beating the boys from “Chariots of Hearth” of their well-known seashore race, and Queen Elizabeth II making her display screen debut reverse Daniel Craig’s James Bond earlier than her stunt double sky-dived into the stadium. It was absolutely one of the best trailer “Skyfall,” which hit theaters a couple of months later, might have hoped for.

The music of the Fab 4 featured closely throughout the ceremony, full with Sir Paul McCartney wrapping issues up by main a sing-a-long to “Hey Jude.” As such, it solely appeared pure {that a} remake of “Yellow Submarine” was additionally slated to coincide with the London Olympics. The dangerous information was that Robert Zemeckis can be mo-capping the Beatles this time round. All of us love the director for traditional films like “Again to the Future,” “Who Framed Roger Rabbit,” and “Forrest Gump,” however his monitor report with motion-capture and CG animation has been divisive (to say the least). 

For some, Zemeckis’ “The Polar Categorical,” “Beowulf,” and “A Christmas Carol” are nearly unwatchable because of the creepy motion-capture fashion that plunges viewers deep into the Uncanny Valley. Fortunately, the director’s “Yellow Submarine” undertaking was canceled, and snippets of footage recommend it might have been a journey to the underside of the Uncanny Mariana Trench. However why, precisely, was it given the chop?

The Beatles on display screen

The Beatles had a tremendous run between their formation in 1960 and their acrimonious breakup a decade later. Aside from turning into arguably Britain’s best cultural export and altering the face of in style music, additionally they discovered time to look in some movies. Cashing in on the Beatlemania phenomenon, the Fab 4 signed up for a three-picture take care of United Artists that began with RIchard Lester’s “A Exhausting Day’s Night time” in 1964. Marking a transition in British cinema from the kitchen-sink realism of the Fifties to the extra celebratory tone of the swinging epoch that got here after, it was one of many finest films of the Nineteen Sixties. Recent, humorous, and pacy, the boys have been clearly having a blast enjoying themselves and taking an irreverent swipe at fame and fan tradition.

“A Exhausting Day’s Night time” was adopted a 12 months later by “Assist!”, the Beatles’ second movie for United Artists. This time, Lester switched to paint for a madcap journey that was additionally successful on the field workplace however typically much less well-regarded. Then got here the Fab 4’s subsequent effort, the made-for-TV highway film “Magical Thriller Tour,” which was an aimless and self-indulgent affair that drew the ire of critics and followers alike. The poor reception additionally made the Beatles cautious about showing in one other characteristic movie, so “Yellow Submarine” turned a work-around to assist fulfill their obligation to United Artists. As an animated musical, they would not have to star in it themselves, though they chipped in with a live-action cameo earlier than jetting off to India to hang around with the Maharishi.

Their final characteristic movie, launched within the 12 months that the Beatles disbanded, was a bittersweet log out. “Let it Be,” a documentary chronicling the rehearsals for his or her ultimate album of the identical identify, concluded with footage of an unannounced rooftop live performance. It was the Beatles’ final public efficiency collectively.

The unique Yellow Submarine

Contrasting with the sharp black-and-white of “A Exhausting Day’s Night time,” “Yellow Submarine” is rooted firmly in mid-’60s psychedelia. The Beatles dabbled with LSD round this time, influencing the sound and lyrics of “Revolver,” “Magical Thriller Tour,” and “Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Membership Band,” whereas the movie’s animation fashion leaned closely into the trippier components of all three.

The movie begins in Pepperland, a peaceable subaquatic utopia that’s below menace from music-hating creatures referred to as the Blue Meanies. Previous Fred, a whiskery sea canine, escapes within the titular submarine and heads off to dirty Liverpool to enlist the assistance of John, Paul, George, and Ringo. Their meandering voyage again to Pepperland is waylaid by a sequence of hallucinatory adventures earlier than they thwart the buzz-killing Chief Blue Meanie and his henchmen with a rendition of “All You Want is Love.”

“Yellow Submarine” usually appears like an excuse to string a bunch of Beatles songs collectively, however there’s hardly something incorrect with that, and the outrageous visuals are actually excellent. Round 200 artists have been employed throughout nearly a 12 months of manufacturing, and the result’s a wildly imaginative fantasia that absolutely had an affect on Terry Gilliam. Standing in for the true Fab 4, John Clive, Geoffrey Hughes, Peter Batten, and Paul Angelis do a good job of mimicking the droll supply of Lennon, McCartney, Harrison, and Starr, respectively. Since we now know the band can be no extra only a few years later, their very late cameo is poignant as they briefly seem to kick off a knees-up with “All Collectively Now.”

The announcement of the Yellow Submarine remake

Dick Prepare dinner, then the chairman of Walt Disney Studios, introduced a remake of “Yellow Submarine” in 2009 on the studio’s D23 expo. Trumpeting the undertaking as “actually an impressed collaboration,” Prepare dinner revealed {that a} licensing take care of Apple Corp Ltd had been struck to make sure that all 16 songs from the unique movie would even be included within the remake, and that Zemeckis can be behind the periscope along with his “pioneering” crew at ImageMovers Digital. Zemeckis acknowledged that making the movie with the most recent 3D motion-capture know-how was a “dream come true.”

Whereas I am positive that some folks have been excited by the prospect, that final half little question despatched shudders down the backbone of many Beatles followers, to not point out lovers of conventional animation and anybody who was given Yuletide nightmares by Zemeckis’ “The Polar Categorical” and “A Christmas Carol.” Certainly, a couple of days after the announcement, Gizmodo printed an opinion piece calling the remake a combination of “unusual hubris” and “a failure of creativeness.”

Potential casting decisions emerged a couple of months later. It wasn’t a nasty line-up: British actors Peter Serafinowicz (“Shaun of the Lifeless”), Dean Lennox Kelly (BBC’s “Robin Hood”), and Adam Campbell (“Shameless”) would play Paul, John, and Ringo respectively, whereas Cary Elwes would lend his vocal abilities as George. Probably the most eye-catching rumor was that David Tennant, then coming to the top of his preliminary stint on the TARDIS controls on “Physician Who,” would star because the Chief Blue Meanie. Come October 2010, nonetheless, there have been indicators that stormy waters lay forward for the movie. Though Zemeckis insisted it was nonetheless a go image, Tennant revealed on a chat present that he thought the undertaking had stalled.

The Yellow Submarine remake sank nearly with no hint

Rumors of budgetary issues emerged earlier than Disney axed each the “Yellow Submarine” remake and ImageMovers Digital in early 2011. Following on from the disappointing efficiency of “A Christmas Carol” on the field workplace, one other dismal exhibiting from “Mars Wants Mothers” supplied the killer blow. Zemeckis sought new backers however, with no takers forthcoming, he was pressured to desert his dream undertaking.

Since then, some early snippets of Zemeckis’ remake have surfaced. Idea artwork exhibits that the imaginative and prescient of Liverpool, with streams of soot billowing into the sky, have been reasonably dystopian, whereas the creature design and the new-look Blue Meanies would have been nothing in need of nightmarish. In the meantime, the reimagined Yellow Submarine was gearing as much as turn into a steampunk craft someplace between the Nautilus in “20,000 Leagues Underneath the Sea” and the illogically spacious inside of the TARDIS. Worst of all, motion-capture of the Fab 4’s cameo within the unique resurrected John Lennon and George Harrison to ghoulish impact.

It might be unfair to guage a canceled film based mostly on pre-production design, however the earlier work of Zemeckis and ImageMovers maybe provides us a reasonably good concept how horrible the completed product would have turned out. If, like me, you hate the creepy mo-cap of “Polar Categorical” and the remaining, you will little question agree we dodged a bullet on this one. Fortunately, we nonetheless bought to see “Yellow Submarine” in time for the London Summer season Olympics when the unique acquired a restricted launch. It could sail again into theaters once more for its fiftieth anniversary in 2018.



Related Articles

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Latest Articles