OPINION — As Israel launches one of the crucial expansive covert-kinetic operations in current reminiscence in opposition to Iranian nuclear infrastructure, a essential query returns: can airpower—supported by superior ISR, precision-guided munitions, and even U.S. bunker-busting weapons—completely dismantle a hardened and decentralized nuclear program? The reply is not any. That continues to be true even when america dedicated its full arsenal of deep-penetration munitions and stealth plane. Iran’s nuclear system is constructed not simply to withstand bodily strikes, however to outlive them—strategically, legally, and doctrinally.
Begin with Fordow, Iran’s most fortified enrichment website. It sits buried 80 to 90 meters deep contained in the Kuh-e Daryacheh mountains. The U.S. GBU-57A/B Huge Ordnance Penetrator can pierce as much as 60 meters of bolstered concrete underneath ultimate circumstances—however it’s not designed to penetrate layers of deep mountain rock, which scatter blast results and scale back influence. Even when a bomb penetrates, it’s not possible to verify the destruction of IR-6 centrifuge arrays or decide the destiny of enriched uranium. Destroying a constructing just isn’t the identical as eliminating the capability for breakout.
Natanz, the better-known website, poses totally different issues. Its amenities are extra uncovered however have already proven resilience. The 2009–2010 Stuxnet assault disrupted rotor speeds; in 2021, an influence grid assault shut down cascades. Each efforts prevented explosive sabotage to forestall aerosolizing saved uranium. Strikes on cascade halls or storage vaults might set off precisely that end result. In the meantime, Iran was constructing new, deeper cascade chambers at Natanz—modeled after Fordow’s hardened design.
However these tactical considerations are simply the floor. Since a minimum of 2003, Iran has remodeled its nuclear program right into a compartmentalized, redundant community. The Atomic Vitality Group of Iran (AEOI) oversees public-facing websites, whereas essential R&D, procurement, and supplies engineering are embedded throughout the Ministry of Protection, the military-linked SPND, and IRGC-run logistics and engineering companies. Universities like Malek Ashtar, Sharif, and Shahid Beheshti—sanctioned for proliferation-related analysis—assist superior work on centrifuge rotors, uranium metallurgy, and simulation fashions. The gas cycle is unfold throughout a number of cities: conversion at Isfahan, enrichment at Fordow and Natanz, heavy water manufacturing at Arak. Knock out one node, and others stay. This technique wasn’t constructed simply to operate—it was constructed to outlive.
The IRGC’s Passive Protection Group has guided this shift because the early 2010s, hardening and camouflaging websites, shifting property underground, and routing logistics by way of civilian infrastructure. Its strategy echoes Soviet and North Korean doctrine: survive the primary strike, reconstitute after. Twin-use amenities, buried nodes, and cell corridors type a system designed to not stop assault, however to soak up it.
A turning level on this evolution was Iran’s transfer to completely home centrifuge manufacturing. Earlier than, Iran relied on illicit procurement networks for delicate elements like rotors and bellows. Now it manufactures them utilizing its personal aerospace and metallurgical sectors. This modification has rendered conventional interdiction methods out of date. There are now not overseas provide chains to focus on. Disrupting manufacturing now means putting sovereign industrial crops not legally outlined as nuclear websites—elevating main questions underneath worldwide regulation about proportionality, attribution, and escalation.
Since Friday, Israel has reportedly killed 14 Iranian nuclear scientists. However the strategic influence might be restricted. These personnel have been a part of a deep and compartmentalized labor construction that features rotor fabrication groups, enrichment system modelers, and logistics engineers—lots of whom stay untouched. Iran’s nuclear data is archived, teachable, and distributed by way of categorized educational applications and military-run technical institutes. Continuity doesn’t depend upon who’s killed—it is dependent upon what survives.
Even when a strike damages amenities, it gained’t present strategic certainty. Since Iran ended its implementation of the JCPOA’s Extra Protocol in 2021, the IAEA has misplaced steady entry to surveillance footage and now not has what Director Normal Rafael Grossi calls “continuity of data.” When inspectors visited the Turquzabad warehouse in 2018—after its publicity by Israeli intelligence—they discovered undeclared nuclear materials. That continues to be the one website revealed, however others might exist. And whereas Iran’s enrichment ranges now far exceed JCPOA limits—the IAEA experiences that Iran holds over 120 kilograms of uranium enriched to 60% U-235, only one step under weapons-grade—its actions technically stay throughout the bounds of the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT), which permits enrichment of any stage so long as it’s not diverted to weapons use. Iran’s uranium steel work at Esfahan, for instance, is ostensibly for reactor gas however has clear relevance for constructing warhead cores. Enrichment cascades, uranium conversion, and simulation software program all stay dual-use by design. A bombing marketing campaign can get rid of gear, however not the authorized narrative, institutional construction, or strategic doctrine that maintain this system.
The weaponization facet is even tougher to focus on. A nuclear gadget requires greater than enriched uranium—it additionally wants implosion programs, neutron initiators, hydrodynamic exams, and precision detonators. Based on the IAEA’s 2011 annex and the Institute for Science and Worldwide Safety experiences from 2019 to 2020, based mostly on paperwork from Iran’s nuclear archive , Iran has explored all of those. Testing on the Parchin navy advanced and archived core design information are a part of the document. These property are usually not solely small and relocatable—they don’t even contain fissile materials. They’re almost not possible to detect by ISR, not to mention destroy, and may solely be verified by way of intrusive on-site inspections. Strategically, Iran just isn’t racing to construct a bomb. It’s positioning itself simply under the edge—capable of weaponize quickly with out overtly violating the NPT. This posture, formalized by Mohsen Fakhrizadeh and internalized throughout SPND, maximizes leverage whereas minimizing authorized threat. And it can’t be destroyed from the air.
Nor will a strike yield dependable post-strike readability. Iran has invested in denial and deception: false facades, buried warmth sources, multispectral camouflage, and encrypted site-to-site communications. These frustrate ISR and make battle injury assessments guesswork. The U.S. confronted comparable points in Iraq from 1991 to 2003, the place cell infrastructure routinely eluded satellite tv for pc and aerial surveillance. Iran’s state of affairs is worse—as a result of there is not any inspector entry, and no ground-truthing. Harm can solely be inferred from secondary signatures like warmth plumes or seismic shockwaves, none of which assure success.
What Iran now possesses is structural latency. That is greater than technical know-how—it’s the power to reconstitute a nuclear program after large-scale bodily degradation. Designs, enriched stockpiles, rotor manufacturing, conversion instruments, simulation fashions, and skilled scientists are unfold throughout the Iranian state. These aren’t hidden threats. They’re sovereign capabilities constructed into the system. The mannequin is comparable to Saddam Hussein’s “just-in-time” reconstitution technique within the Nineteen Nineties: Iraq had no bombs, however preserved sufficient design knowledge and networks to restart underneath higher circumstances. Iran has intentionally adopted that very same logic. So long as authorized ambiguity is preserved, scientists stay protected, and amenities go uninspected, no strike can destroy the true core of this system.
Widespread analogies are deceptive. Israel’s 1981 strike on Iraq’s Osirak reactor labored as a result of the power was pre-operational, had no uranium gas, and no supporting infrastructure. There was no gas cycle, no cascade system, and no redundancy. None of that applies to Iran. At present’s program is hardened, dispersed, and much nearer to the nuclear threshold. Osirak is now not a related mannequin.
There’s additionally no historic precedent for dismantling a program as deeply embedded as Iran’s with out bodily entry. Libya’s 2003 disarmament adopted years of behind-the-scenes negotiations and was catalyzed not simply by concern of invasion, however by Gaddafi’s need to normalize relations with Western banks and oil markets. Libya by no means enriched uranium domestically; its centrifuges have been nonetheless in crates, acquired by way of the A.Q. Khan community, and its warhead designs have been copies of Pakistani blueprints. South Africa, in contrast, had constructed six nuclear weapons—however it dismantled them in secret between 1989 and 1991 underneath a tightly managed home program, then revealed their existence solely after apartheid’s finish to facilitate worldwide reintegration. The method was pushed by regime transition, not exterior strain, and was verified solely after full IAEA entry. Syria’s al-Kibar reactor, destroyed by Israel in 2007, was based mostly on a North Korean gas-graphite design and had no assist infrastructure: no enrichment, no reprocessing, and no declared vitality program to obscure it. No bombing marketing campaign can replicate the political and technical circumstances that enabled disarmament in these circumstances.
A really efficient dismantlement would resemble not strikes, however a floor incursion. It will contain seizing Fordow and Natanz, securing uranium stockpiles, capturing cascade schematics and procurement data, and both debriefing or eradicating scientists tied to the IRGC, AEOI, and college analysis applications. It will require IAEA and intelligence personnel embedded on-site, conducting forensic audits in centrifuge labs, metallurgy workshops, and simulation facilities. That is what labored in Iraq and Libya: management, not simply precision. No air marketing campaign can try this from 35,000 toes.
At finest, the airstrikes will purchase time. At worst, they may destroy inspection leverage, push this system additional underground—each bodily and politically—and threat triggering the very breakout they intention to forestall. They provide the looks of decision, not its substance. Denial, whether it is to be actual, should transcend non permanent disruption. It should imply verified elimination of capability, management of personnel, and bodily entry to infrastructure. The laborious fact is that this: if disarmament is the purpose—as President Trump insists when he says Iran mustn’t ever purchase a nuclear weapon—then airstrikes alone gained’t obtain it.
The Cipher Transient is dedicated to publishing a variety of views on nationwide safety points submitted by deeply skilled nationwide safety professionals.
Opinions expressed are these of the writer and don’t symbolize the views or opinions of The Cipher Transient.
Have a perspective to share based mostly in your expertise within the nationwide safety subject? Ship it to Editor@thecipherbrief.com for publication consideration.
Learn extra expert-driven nationwide safety insights, perspective and evaluation in The Cipher Transient
