:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/faw-muffin-pan-single-group-editor-test-dillon-evans-03-1-e4281ea09a51438d9ba33263b654f55f.jpeg?w=1920&resize=1920,1267&ssl=1 "The three Greatest Muffin Pans of 2025, Examined & Reviewed")
A muffin pan is a kind of baking instruments you must totally analysis earlier than buying. Not like cake pans or brownie pans, the small cavities in muffin pans imply shorter baking occasions, faster heating, and fewer room for error. Selecting a muffin pan with even warmth distribution and balanced warmth reactivity will enable you obtain tender, absolutely cooked meals — whether or not it’s muffins and cupcakes or different muffin pan recipes.
To seek out the muffin pans that yield one of the best outcomes, I examined eight fashions from knowledgeable bakeware producers, together with Fats Daddio’s, Nice Jones, Nordic Ware, and extra. After working every tin by the gauntlet, I discovered that one of the best muffin pans baked meals till that they had crispy exteriors, moist interiors, and little or no left to scrub on the pan. Plus, that they had useful equipment and designs to make dealing with simpler. Learn on to see which pans stood out. The outcomes might shock you.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/muffintin2-c05cc30511fa4e29b649f6e99da13996.jpg)
The Nice Jones Stud Muffin is remarkably designed. This muffin pan’s nonstick ceramic coating is dual-layered and extremely efficient. It even coats the crevice between the platform (the flat portion of the pan) and the cavities, stopping meals particles and moisture from getting caught in between. This design characteristic made releasing muffins and cleansing the pan simpler than all of the others I examined.
The Stud Muffin has wire-reinforced rims and prolonged ends which are simple to seize with oven mitts. Like magic, this pan baked each blueberry muffins and mashed potato bites with darkish, crispy crusts and moist interiors. The cavities have a goldilocks width, sized completely for baking with or with out cupcake liners. The one take a look at this muffin pan handed with out full marks was the hard-boiled egg take a look at, because the egg whites didn’t launch from their shells as cleanly as with different pans. In any other case, that is an impressive muffin pan, and we like that it is available in two vibrant colorways, blueberry and raspberry, to set it other than different bakeware.
Supplies: Aluminized metal and nonstick ceramic coating | Dimensions: 15.25 x 11 x 1.25 inches | Most Temperature: 450°F | Dishwasher-safe: Sure, hand-wash beneficial
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/oxo-5ad9635a7d74480a85a2a4086b616ebd.jpg)
I used to be gobsmacked after I noticed the value of OXO’s muffin pan after testing it. It’s the second least costly I examined, which is shocking contemplating its glorious efficiency. The OXO’s distinctive characteristic is the place of its cavities: They sit barely under the platform, quite than curving over it, giving muffins room to develop. The house between cavities is substantial, as is the just about 2 inches of dealing with room at every finish. The general development weighs greater than twice the load of some others I examined, and it has sturdy rolled rims to forestall warping.
Regardless of this muffin pan’s heavy construct, the cavities are surprisingly slim. Cupcake liners match tightly into the cavities, creating comparatively petite cupcakes. Once I baked muffins straight within the pan, the muffin bottoms had been small, though the muffin tops had loads of room to rise. In comparison with the Nice Jones mannequin, the OXO was a detailed second in baking efficiency. Browning was nearly as even, however there have been tiny but noticeable spots the place the browning was much less constant than with the Nice Jones pan. This muffin pan’s notable disadvantage is the crevices between cavities and the platform, which I needed to away from meals bits utilizing a toothpick. However I’d fortunately proceed to take action for a muffin pan of this caliber at its impressively low value.
Supplies: Aluminized metal and nonstick ceramic coating | Dimensions: 16.96 x 11.9 x 1.65 inches | Most Temperature: 450°F | Dishwasher-safe: No
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/lodge-d5746c63e59841d5a38aaf9b6daa2143.jpg)
Not everybody desires to make a dozen muffins or cupcakes. When six or fewer is sufficient, the Lodge forged iron muffin pan is a sound alternative. Like all of our favourite forged iron kitchenware, this muffin pan requires correct reseasoning. Nevertheless, it’s a steady mould without having for toothpicking crevices. It’s simple to hold, on account of its small dimension, and it’s the one muffin pan I examined that has precise handles.
This pan yielded muffins that had a good crumb and tall rise. It additionally baked “hard-boiled” eggs one of the best of any pan — every egg was absolutely cooked and noticeably simpler to peel. If you may get previous the comparatively costly price ticket, this can be a lifetime buy that matches seamlessly right into a small-batch baker’s kitchen.
Supplies: Forged iron | Dimensions: 12.69 x 7.06 x 1.56 inches | Most Temperature: 650°F | Dishwasher-safe: No
How I Examined Muffin Pans
I discovered one of the best muffin pans after rigorously testing eight top-rated fashions. For this take a look at, we included muffin pans made of varied supplies, in several sizes, and from a various group of producers. I evaluated every pan in just a few methods:
- Muffin take a look at: I began by baking the identical blueberry muffin recipe in every pan to look at variations in browning, moisture, and rise. I famous any occurrences of burning, an excessive amount of unfold, underbaking, or every other points.
- Versatility take a look at: I paired pans of comparable efficiency within the muffin take a look at collectively to gauge their efficiency in different areas. On this take a look at, I used every muffin pan to bake meals aside from muffins, together with lined and unlined cupcakes, mashed potato bites, and mini meatloaves.
- Onerous-boiled egg take a look at: I “hard-boiled” eggs in each pan to check for even cooking between cavities and warmth conductivity over time.
- Cleansing and care: I adopted the producer’s directions to hand-wash all of the muffin pans and famous particulars, akin to most oven temperatures and urged cleansing merchandise. I additionally cleaned any dishwasher-safe muffin pans within the dishwasher, observing how they fared after every wash.
As soon as I accomplished my assessments, I appeared on the costs of every pan. Lastly, I weighed value in opposition to baking efficiency and design to find out every mannequin’s general worth.
Meals & Wine
Components to Think about
Platform Design
Good muffin pans are simple to seize from the oven. Most muffin pans are constructed with platforms that stretch on reverse sides for grabbing onto. Others have built-in handles which are simple to grip securely. Whether or not the pan has handles or solely a platform, I discovered that at the very least an inch of dealing with room between the outermost cavities and the rim widthwise was loads of clearance for transferring the pans out and in of the oven. Muffin pans with lower than 1 inch of clearance had been tough to seize when sizzling from the oven.
The platform also needs to have sufficient clearance between the outermost cavities and the rim lengthwise. Muffin pans that lacked this house prompted batter and oils to drip over the perimeters and onto the oven ground.
Meals & Wine
Cavity Dimension
Muffin pans are sometimes accessible in three sizes: jumbo, mini, and customary. Jumbo muffin pan cavities can maintain about 8 ounces of batter, and mini tins often high off at 2 ounces. Normal muffin pans, the sort I examined, have a cavity capability between 3 to 4 fluid ounces. For normal muffin pans, cavities with lower than a 3-ounce quantity are likely to create brief, stubby muffins. Typically, these smaller cavities are additionally wider than others, making them unaccommodating to cupcake liners.
Meals & Wine
Cleansing and Care
To wash muffin pans, hand-washing is nearly a given. Solely our high decide is dishwasher-safe, however Nice Jones nonetheless suggests hand-washing it. Crucial factor to look at on any muffin pan is the crevice between the platform and the cavities. If moisture will get trapped there, your pan might rust over time. Caught-on crumbs, in the meantime, may result in a foodborne sickness. Thoughtfully designed muffin pans are sealed tightly on the crevices to maintain each water and meals out. Regardless of the pan, nevertheless, you will have to make use of a toothpick or different pointy instrument to fish crumbs out of crevices when vital.
Meals & Wine
Different Muffin Pans I Examined
Sturdy Contenders
Meals & Wine
Silpat The Authentic Excellent Muffin Mould ($65 at Amazon)
Severe bakers will love this muffin mould for its easy nonstick design and heat-reactive baking surroundings. But, it might be costly for the typical residence baker, demand temperature and time changes, or require additional purchases like a cookie sheet or perforated pan.
Meals & Wine
Williams Sonoma Goldtouch Professional Nonstick Muffin Pan ($40 at Williams Sonoma)
This light-weight pan carried out pretty properly in all assessments, however its warmth reactivity was lighter than others, leading to much less constant bakes.
Meals & Wine
USA Pan Bakeware 12-Properly Muffin Pan ($32 at Amazon)
Nothing sticks to this muffin pan, and it’s a cinch to scrub. It bakes meals very slowly, nevertheless, which is nice to keep away from burning, however not so nice for following recipes.
What Did not Make the Record
Meals & Wine
Nordic Ware Sensible Muffin Pan ($24 at Amazon)
Nordic Ware’s latest muffin pan has pure aluminum cavities, metal rims, and a nonstick coating. It didn’t find yourself on our listing as a result of the pan was too compact, making it laborious to carry, and the aluminum cavities are fragile sufficient to bend on the push of a finger.
Meals & Wine
Fats Daddio’s Anodized Aluminum Normal Muffin Pan ($26 at Amazon)
Fats Daddio’s designed a pan that bakes muffins with an evenly browned crust. I discovered the cavities too extensive, nevertheless, and the quantity of sticking, even after utilizing baking spray, too inconvenient in comparison with the nonstick fashions. If you would like a comparatively cheap muffin pan and solely plan to make use of liners, or grease and flour, this muffin pan should still be helpful for you.
Our Experience
Dillon Evans is a Meals & Wine Replace Author, licensed cake decorator, and lifelong residence baker. He has expertise testing many kitchen merchandise, together with bundt pans, cake adorning instruments, and cake stands. In penning this roundup, he carried out product analysis to assist choose muffin pans to check and used his years of cake-decorating and baking expertise to guage every product. The primary dessert Dillon ever baked was a batch of muffins, and he unintentionally swapped salt for sugar.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/faw-muffin-pan-single-group-editor-test-dillon-evans-03-1-e4281ea09a51438d9ba33263b654f55f.jpeg?w=1200&resize=1200,0&ssl=1&description=The+three+Greatest+Muffin+Pans+of+2025%2C+Examined+%26+Reviewed){kind=link}