Henry Cavill was formally changed as Superman for James Gunn’s new DC Universe, however a brand new report says the actor was thought of to be recast years earlier than that. The DC Prolonged Universe ended ignominiously again in 2023 with a string of flops that appeared to deliver an emphatic finish to this beleaguered shared timeline. It adopted one of many strangest and damaging moments in DCEU historical past with 2022’s “Black Adam.” That film, whereby The Rock received to reside out his fantasy of enjoying a DC hero whereas concurrently making an attempt to achieve management of DC’s cinematic tasks as a complete, featured Henry Cavill’s Man of Metal in a cameo that was heralded as an official return for the British star. The actor’s tenure as Supes started with Zack Snyder’s “Man of Metal” in 2013 and beforehand appeared to have ended with “Zack Snyder’s Justice League” in 2021. “Black Adam,” nevertheless, was alleged to reintroduce his Superman to the lots.
However Johnson and Cavill’s weird makes an attempt to remain within the DCEU merely did not work. “Black Adam” simply did not make sufficient cash, and as soon as the superheroic field workplace bomb that was “The Flash” arrived in 2023, DC’s shared universe was on its final legs — a lot to the dismay of the so-called “Snyderverse” followers, a few of are planning on doing all they’ll to wreck Gunn’s forthcoming “Superman.”
With that film imminent, we’re set to enter into a whole new section of DC motion pictures — one the place Cavill is most actually not enjoying Superman. However it appears that evidently even earlier than Gunn launched his new DC Universe, the British actor was going to be recast for a narrative that may, presumably, have taken place throughout the now defunct DCEU.
Henry Cavill was going to be recast as Superman through the DCEU run
In an Leisure Weekly function, James Gunn revealed that Warner Bros. had reached out to him previous to 2021’s “The Suicide Squad,” itself meant to reintroduce audiences to the titular workforce after David Ayer’s “Suicide Squad” was met with disappointment again in 2016. Gunn was requested to overtake Activity Power X after Ayer’s try, however it appears he was additionally requested to re-envision Superman.
In accordance with Gunn, Warner Bros. supplied him an opportunity to direct a Supes film earlier than “The Suicide Squad,” and particularly wished Henry Cavill’s Superman recast. That might have meant the actor would have been changed previous to his cameo in 2022’s “Black Adam.” As Gunn defined, “It was much more messy than it’s now,” which is placing it flippantly.
In the direction of the top of the DCEU, issues had gotten convoluted sufficient with Zack Snyder having departed 2017’s “Justice League” and handing directorial duties to Joss Whedon. That film didn’t resonate with audiences, and by 2021, there studio was satisfied to permit the so-called “Snyder minimize” of “Justice League” to be given an official launch. When that movie did arrive in 2021, it featured Cavill’s Superman.
Just by advantage of present, then, “Zack Snyder’s Justice League” appeared to counsel Warner Bros. wasn’t completely in opposition to Cavill representing the Man of Metal going ahead, and “Black Adam” supplied but extra proof. However in keeping with Gunn, the studio was set on changing Cavill lengthy earlier than Snyder was granted permission to complete his imaginative and prescient of the Justice League. Why did not such a factor really occur? Properly, the brand new DC Studios head stated he merely wasn’t prepared on the time. “I did not have that particular concept of what that [film] can be,” stated Gunn, who has just lately spoken about wanting his “Superman” film to be about one factor.
James Gunn is directing the Superman film he was alleged to
The top of the DCEU was nothing wanting a debacle. A behind-the-scenes energy battle that resulted in former DC Movies head Walter Hamada leaving Warner Bros. did not precisely bode nicely for the franchise, and after “Black Adam,” “The Flash,” and “Shazam! Fury of the Gods” didn’t ship commercially and critically, the shared universe that began with Henry Cavill and Zack Snyder again in 2013 got here to an finish. Would issues had been totally different had we received a James Gunn-directed Superman film previous to the DCEU’s closure? Maybe, however even with that in thoughts, it looks like a darn good factor that this earlier Gunn-helmed film did not materialize.
For one factor, the DCEU already appeared to be flailing on the time, and I am unsure a brand new Superman would have been all it took to proper the ship. What’s extra, the director would have been considerably restricted by having to make his film match the broader DCEU aesthetic, which looks like it could have been far too stifling an expertise for somebody with Gunn’s distinct fashion and sensibilities. Significantly better to have the person oversee a complete new movie in a complete new universe the place he can fail or succeed on his personal deserves. What’s extra, Cavill all the time appeared like an amazing Superman who by no means actually received an amazing Superman story, so merely recasting the actor whereas sustaining the primary DCEU storyline does not look like it could have been the very best concept.
The query now’s, will audiences who appear to have lengthy since uninterested in superhero storytelling — arguably in response to the kind of nonsense that characterised the demise of the DCEU — reply to Gunn’s imaginative and prescient and David Corenswet’s Man of Metal? We’ll discover out when “Superman” flies into theaters on July 11, 2025.
