The Drama Behind Silver Lake Queer Bar the Ruby Fruit’s Sudden Closure

The Ruby Fruit, a Silver Lake “strip mall wine bar for the sapphically inclined,” closed all of the sudden on January 11, 2025, after two years of enterprise, amid the chaos of the Los Angeles wildfires. The house owners, Emily Bielagus and Mara Herbkersman, introduced the closure in a now-deleted Instagram publish that learn, “We have now come to the heartbreaking choice that presently, working the Ruby Fruit is now not attainable on account of monetary affect from the present pure catastrophe.” The publish went on to say: “The maths simply isn’t mathing.”

The preliminary response to the closure was largely an outpouring of shock and heartbreak within the Instagram feedback, with many commenters asking how they might assist or if the Ruby Fruit deliberate to begin a GoFundMe to reopen. In distinction to these providing assist, dozens of different commenters alleged that they’d not felt welcome on the bar. After the Ruby Fruit closed, a number of media retailers lined the information, together with an op-ed that rooted for the Silver Lake wine bar to reopen; one other mentioned its monetary struggles. A few month after the preliminary closure, on February 12, LGBTQ publication the Blade revealed a report during which former workers alleged mistreatment within the office. The report additionally included allegations of trans and BIPOC prospects not feeling welcome within the bar.

On February 6, Bielagus and Herbkersman put out an announcement on Instagram addressing the feedback and occasions surrounding the closure, writing that they at all times supposed the Ruby Fruit to be an inclusive house. The assertion reemphasized that the explanation for the sudden closure was monetary struggles and instructed that they’re at all times open to additional dialog. Feedback on this publish had been turned off. A few week later, on February 12, the duo deleted the bar’s Instagram account fully.

The Ruby Fruit was one of the outstanding openings in 2023 and earned Eater LA’s Greatest New Group Restaurant award that very same yr. With nearly all of LA’s queer bars catering to homosexual males, the Ruby Fruit’s closure marked a somber reminder of town’s lack of lesbian and nonbinary areas.

Eater spoke with Bielagus, Herbkersman, and two staff to look at the occasions for the reason that closure. Right here’s all the things to learn about what’s occurring with the Ruby Fruit.

What’s the Ruby Fruit?

The Ruby Fruit, named as an homage to Rita Mae Brown’s 1973 coming-of-age novel Rubyfruit Jungle, debuted as a Silver Lake wine bar for Los Angeles’s sapphic neighborhood on February 21, 2023. (Them, an LGBTQ information publication, defines sapphic as “an umbrella time period that features lesbian, bisexual, and pansexual trans femmes, mascs, nonbinary people, and cis ladies.”) Bielagus and Herbkersman met and have become mates whereas working at Eszett, an off-the-cuff wine bar beforehand occupying the Ruby Fruit house, finally internet hosting sapphic nights they known as Leszett.

Throughout its tenure, the Ruby Fruit supplied wine, beer, cocktails, and low alongside a lunch and dinner menu with consolation dishes like popcorn hen, a furikake Caesar salad, deviled eggs, and grilled wings. The bar was additionally a well-liked venue for occasions like comedy exhibits, coworking, and dwell music.

“I had at all times mentioned I needed to open a lesbian bar earlier than I turned 40,” Bielagus explains. “Mara had at all times had that very same dream and that’s how we bonded once we had been working collectively. Fairly merely, we needed an area the place the sapphic neighborhood felt protected to go, and we knew that there wasn’t that house in LA.”

Whereas Los Angeles has quite a few lesbian and queer occasions, the one everlasting lesbian bar outdoors of the Ruby Fruit was Honey’s at Star Love, which opened in February 2023. Although LA’s lesbian bars had been outstanding in many years previous, in 2019, the lone lesbian bar within the second-largest metropolis in America was a pop-up known as the Fingerjoint.

What does it imply to be a sapphically inclined bar?

Within the wake of the bar’s closure, commenters on Instagram raised questions on why the Ruby Fruit referred to itself as a “sapphically inclined” bar as a substitute of a “lesbian bar,” particularly since the bar’s GoFundMe refers to it as a “lesbian bar.”

Agua, a former worker of the Ruby Fruit who solely needs to be recognized by their first title, alleges that Herbkersman emphasised that the bar needs to be for “everybody,” as a substitute of being centered on simply the lesbian neighborhood.

Bielagus says they used the phrases “sapphically inclined,” “lesbian,” and “sapphic neighborhood” interchangeably for the reason that bar opened. “I do know that there are individuals who really feel that the phrase ‘lesbian’ doesn’t embrace them, and I believe the phrase sapphic is a bigger umbrella that features the gender-expansive neighborhood, the trans neighborhood, and the nonbinary neighborhood,” she says. “We additionally needed to be clear that the phrase ‘lesbian’ is an okay phrase; we didn’t wish to be like, ‘“Lesbian” is a grimy phrase.’ It’s simply generally not the one phrase for the neighborhood we needed to serve.”

What introduced in regards to the Ruby Fruit’s closure?

In accordance with Bielagus and Herbkersman, the Ruby Fruit has been “susceptible” since opening. The duo opened the bar two weeks after Eszett’s closure when the earlier house owners supplied them the house; Eszett closed on January 20, 2023, and the Ruby Fruit opened on February 21, 2023.

Bielagus says that the bar was busy when it first opened however began to see a shift on the finish of 2023, concurrent with the SAG-AFTRA strike. She says that it turned clear that folks had fewer sources to spend, and the shoppers that did are available didn’t spend as a lot. Some prospects had been affected immediately and weren’t working on the time. Bielagus says that after the strikes, enterprise by no means actually normalized to the mid-2023 numbers.

Agua says that from the again of the home, the bar appeared busy after they began working there in March 2024 as a line prepare dinner and later after they had been promoted to sous chef. However they are saying that after they converted to the morning shift, it was a “very totally different tempo,” citing challenges in competing with the favored brunch restaurant Millie’s subsequent door.

Herbkersman says that whereas the bar was capable of pay its workers and payments, it by no means turned a revenue and wasn’t capable of save sufficient to have a security internet. Bielagus provides that all through the bar’s run, she and Herbkersman had been making an attempt to safe buyers and extra monetary backing however had been “stretched skinny” whereas making an attempt to deal with day-to-day operations and work on the bar.

After the Palisades and Eaton fires broke out in Los Angeles on January 7, 2025, the Ruby Fruit paused operations for a day to judge the state of affairs. After the bar reopened, gross sales dropped 90 %, bringing in an estimated $600 for the day. “That’s when the panic actually set in,” Herbkersman says. “Once we’re speaking about being susceptible, the road is so skinny between having the ability to stick with it and never. It turned actually clear after two days of being open that if we had been to go on another day, we’d run the danger of not having the ability to pay our staff, a nonnegotiable for us.” The pair realized they solely had sufficient cash within the financial institution for payroll as much as the shut on January 11. “The {dollars} made that call for us,” Herbkersman says.

Agua alleges that the enterprise had been struggling for a while. “Each single day, they might be, like, ‘We’re going broke,’” they are saying. After notifying staff of the rapid closure by way of electronic mail, Bielagus and Herbkersman took to Instagram to make the announcement. “I believe they clearly had been fighting cash for a very long time,” says Sienna Deadrich, a former line prepare dinner on the Ruby Fruit. The duo attributed the closure to the “monetary affect from the present pure catastrophe.”

Some commenters took the assertion as Bielagus and Herbkersman blaming the closure on the fireplace, regardless that the bar was in a roundabout way affected. Bielagus clarifies that they didn’t imply in charge it on the fires, however as a substitute needed to spotlight how delicate the enterprise was. “Something would have completed us in,” she says.

On January 13, Bielagus and Herbkersman hosted a Zoom assembly with former workers. Whereas Herbkersman says the meet was a possibility for employees to air their grievances and ask questions, and a few even inspired them to begin a GoFundMe, Agua hoped that workers might have a dialog about office points. However that by no means materialized for the reason that restaurant was closing.

Instagram

The place are these allegations about office points coming from?

Within the feedback part below the fundraising publish, a handful of alleged former staff made allegations of mistreatment and different office points throughout their time working on the Ruby Fruit. The Blade studies that a number of former staff who wished to stay nameless on account of worry of retaliation reached out to the publication. “The disappointment I really feel in regards to the closure of the bar is far smaller in comparison with the frustration and damage I skilled working there,” an nameless former worker advised the Blade.

“The responses from workers are surprising as a result of it’s not consistent with what we supposed or understood was the temperature of it,” Herbkersman says. “It’s devastating to lose a job. I imply, we’ve all been there, but it surely simply felt like a giant shock.”

Agua says that their expertise working on the Ruby Fruit began positively, particularly as a result of they had been capable of work with so many different queer folks. However as they settled into the function additional and bought comfy, “toxicity from the house owners” emerged that left staff feeling like their experiences working there didn’t line up with the inclusivity Bielagus and Herbkersman had touted. “I made superb mates and an incredible neighborhood out of that house,” they are saying. “However when it was unhealthy, it was unhealthy. It felt like I used to be strolling on eggshells.” They allege that being one of many few folks of colour engaged on the core staff made their expertise tougher, they usually felt “remoted” at work.

Deadrich mentions that coworkers instructed neighborhood occasions hosted by folks of colour, however alleges that their concepts had been discouraged. “A whole lot of the workers had been youthful queer folks of colour. We needed to attempt one thing within the house subsequent door. Two of my coworkers tried to plan a queer film night time. Agua and I needed to do a few sit-down dinners and a e book night time.” Deadrich turned discouraged upon being introduced with two choices: both hire the house for $4,000 and promote their very own tickets, or pay nothing and the occasion can be hosted by the Ruby Fruit. “I used to be pissed off that both I must pay $4,000 or have them revenue off of my concepts and labor,” says Deadrich.

“I used to be employed below the concept that everybody had a voice or one thing to say,” Deadrich says. “I believe Mara and Emily tried to cover below this veil of inclusion. However then, when it truly got here all the way down to it, I’d attempt to give my concepts they usually had been simply at all times sort of like, ‘No matter.’”

“I felt very tokenized all through my time there,” Agua says. “To see different folks of colour share that related expertise as me was very hurtful, as a result of nobody ought to ever expertise racism or any kind of bigotry. Nevertheless it was very validating, and I didn’t really feel remoted in my expertise.”

Deadrich alleges that workers had introduced their considerations in regards to the office and inclusivity to Bielagus and Herbkersman previously. “We talked to them about it, they usually sort of simply glossed over it,” they are saying.

Bielagus says that studying the feedback below the Instagram publish was “heartbreaking,” and that they “shifted issues internally” to assist essentially the most susceptible whereas the bar was open, like sharing suggestions throughout the complete workers, from managers to dishwashers. Nonetheless, Herbkersman says that they had been “underresourced.”

Herbkersman and Bielagus say that they need they did extra “concrete” issues like DEI coaching for employees, and had extra insurance policies in place to discover that. “We perceive that as a missed alternative.” Herbkersman provides that the feedback haven’t been “unheard” or “ignored,” and that she sees and reads them. “I would like and relish the chance to deal with these issues,” she says.

How has the Ruby Fruit responded to allegations of being noninclusive?

Alongside allegations from former staff, some commenters alleged that the Ruby Fruit had been unwelcoming to trans and BIPOC prospects. “I don’t suppose they purposefully didn’t embrace them,” says Deadrich. “However from the attitude of somebody who’s POC and trans, it was very clear that they didn’t embrace them.” Deadrich and Agua each allege that when considerations about inclusivity had been introduced up, Bielagus and Herbkersman would brush them off.” Deadrich recollects one occasion when Herbkersman allegedly got here into the kitchen speaking about what folks had been saying on-line in regards to the bar. Deadrich says, “She was identical to, ‘We’re a queer house, and everybody’s welcome right here,’ and all that sort of stuff. ‘I don’t know why they’re saying these types of issues.’”

“It’s actually stunning,” Herbkersman says of the feedback on Instagram. “I believe we’re simply in shock about it. It’s not consistent with something that we got down to do.” She says that the “dialog of inclusivity” has at all times been a subject on the Ruby Fruit and that they’ve labored to verify their messaging was consistent with their imaginative and prescient of the bar being a “radically inclusive house.”

“To listen to somebody accuse us of being TERFs is rather like gut-wrenching as a result of it’s so removed from the intention and what we had been actually making an attempt to perform,” Herbkersman says. TERF is an acronym that stands for trans-exclusionary radical feminist.

Bielagus says that they had been at all times aware of making an attempt to incorporate trans folks, nonbinary folks, and BIPOC in conversations about what folks needed from the bar, and what it might provide. “The Ruby Fruit was by no means nearly us,” Bielagus says. “It was about guaranteeing that others round us are lifted up.”

Instagram

What’s up with the GoFundMe fundraisers?

Bielagus and Herbkersman began the primary GoFundMe on January 12, 2025, the day after the Ruby Fruit closed, to assist the laid-off workers. The fundraiser was capped at $15,000, which Bielagus and Herbkersman allege is the equal of 1 further paycheck for employees, whereas Deadrich alleges that it will come out to lower than a paycheck for employees. They allege that workers had been additionally not conscious that Bielagus and Herbkersman had been planning to begin the GoFundMe. “We saved on being like, ‘Let’s speak about this as a staff, as a bunch,’” Deadrich says. “They usually saved on simply posting stuff for us with out speaking about it earlier than.” Additionally they describe the timing of the unique GoFundMe as “insensitive” amid the continuing fires. “So many Black and brown households are posting their GoFundMes as a result of they’re dropping their homes, and also you guys can’t pay your staff since you guys are unhealthy enterprise house owners,” they are saying. Bielagus shares a special account, saying that they had been “acutely aware of that second” and needed “to pay attention to how this slot in with the remainder of the fundraising that was happening on the time.”

On February 5, after about 25 days open, the Ruby Fruit closed the worker fundraiser at round $13,000, which was $2,000 shy of its objective. The funds have since been distributed to staff.

On the identical day, Bielagus and Herbkersman introduced a brand new fundraiser to save lots of the Ruby Fruit, with a objective of $100,000, together with a charity occasion known as Leather-based & Lace. Former staff had been confused by the shuttering of their GoFundMe to begin a brand new one. “We had been supposed to fulfill the objective of $15,000, however as quickly as they began their new objective of funding $100,000 they deleted ours,” Agua alleges. “Individuals had been nonetheless making an attempt to donate, and so we by no means even met the objective — we had been sort of simply neglected once more of the dialog.” Deadrich says that the brand new GoFundMe felt like “a slap within the face.”

Herbkersman defends the selection to shut the worker GoFundMe and begin a brand new one to save lots of the bar. “It was mandatory for us to begin to shift our focus onto the enterprise as a complete,” she says. “In any other case, the choice of even ever hiring them again can be inconceivable. If we will’t get the enterprise again, then we will’t do something for anybody ever.”

Agua additionally alleges that the workers had no prior information of the fundraiser or the occasion. “That publish simply occurred out of nowhere, and we’re like, ‘What’s happening?’” Bielagus and Herbkersman allege that inside an hour of the posting going up, they reached out to former staff to supply jobs working on the occasion. “They weren’t completely happy that they’d not been knowledgeable that we had been holding that occasion,” Herbkersman says.

“One thing I actually wish to clarify is now we have at all times been very open with our workers,” Bielagus says. “We’ve included them in all the selections that they should be included in. However we additionally have to make some monetary choices which might be actually necessary to our enterprise with out together with them in these choices.”

Is the Leather-based & Lace occasion nonetheless occurring?

In accordance with Bielagus and Herbkersman, the Leather-based & Lace occasion has been canceled with refunds issued to ticket holders. On the time of cancellation, they’d bought 50 common tickets and all VIP tables.

What have the house owners mentioned for the reason that closure?

On February 6, Bielagus and Herbkersman put out an announcement on Instagram with a title card that mentioned, “A message from the Ruby Fruit,” addressing the closure and Instagram feedback. Within the publish on the now-deleted Instagram account, Bielagus and Herbkersman wrote that the bar “has at all times been and can at all times stay devoted to inclusivity” and has at all times “welcomed open dialogue.”

The publish went on to make clear that the choice to pause operations was immediately knowledgeable by the fireplace, and the sharp lack of enterprise, including that they solely had sufficient to pay workers for another day.

Bielagus and Herbkersman additionally wrote that they had been reviewing their insurance policies and evaluating the enterprise transferring ahead together with offering range, fairness, and inclusion coaching for administration and workers; enhancing office insurance policies; establishing clearer reporting mechanisms for office grievances; and inspiring extra open communication.

What’s at present occurring within the Ruby Fruit house?

Coco’s to Go-Go, run by culinary producer and chef Courtney Storer, is at present operating a aid kitchen out of the previous Ruby Fruit house.

What’s subsequent for the Ruby Fruit?

On February 12, Bielagus and Herbkersman put out an announcement on the GoFundMe to reopen the Ruby Fruit, saying they “absolutely plan to re-open [the] doorways as a protected house for LA’s Sapphic neighborhood.” Whereas the fundraiser is paused, they withdrew $3,926.89 on February 14 from GoFundMe to maintain the enterprise afloat and can put the funds in direction of utilities, hire, and excellent vendor funds. In a follow-up assertion to Eater LA, Bielagus and Herbkersman say that they’re “unsure of any future plans for the Ruby Fruit.”

Agua says that for the reason that bar closed, folks have requested them if they might work there once more if it reopens. They are saying they might be open to it if it had been employee-run and -owned. “The one means the Ruby Fruit can occur once more is that if Emily and Mara are now not house owners, or in the event that they step again,” they are saying. “The identical factor will proceed occurring in the event that they’re in management positions.”

As of February 21, the Ruby Fruit remains to be promoting a $150 sweatshirt that reads, “I saved the Ruby Fruit, and all I bought was this awful sweatshirt.”